They will say they are citing CDC guidance, of course. But one thing that has become abundantly clear over the course of the pandemic is who the CDC actually works for.
A union for flight attendants is
accusing the CDC of loosening rules for quarantine after Covid-19
exposure at the behest of the airline industry, as the Omicron variant
continues to rage across the globe.
"We said we wanted to hear from
medical professionals on the best guidance for quarantine, not from
corporate America advocating for a shortened period due to staffing
shortages,” said Association of Flight Attendants-CWA International
President Sara Nelson following the CDC announcement shortening the recommended quarantine duration from 10 days to five days.
“The CDC gave a medical explanation about why the agency has decided to
reduce the quarantine requirements from 10 to five days, but the fact
that it aligns with the number of days pushed by corporate America is
less than reassuring,” Nelson said.
It really isn't even a big secret. When pressed on the matter, CDC leadership openly admits they are considering factors besides the public health question. They are, instead, prioritizing an agenda pushed corporate lobbyists which insists that sick leave time is a threat to"societal function."
The decision to cut the recommended isolation time in half, which
was hailed by business groups and slammed by some union leaders and
health experts, reflects the increasingly tough decisions health
officials navigate as they seek to strike the right balance between
vigilance and normalcy as the nation heads into the pandemic’s third
year. Even with a surging variant, President Biden has said he is
not looking at lockdowns and stressed that people who are vaccinated
and boosted do not need to fundamentally change their lives as they did
at the start of the pandemic.
The
guidance by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) “was
based on the anticipation of a large number of cases might impact
societal function,” CDC Director Rochelle Walensky said in an interview
with The Post. “There were starting to be limitations in society, not
just in our health-care workforce but in other parts of society. We were
seeing infections in many places that we realized this could be a
harbinger of many other essential workers we needed.”
"There were starting to be limitations in society." In other words, workers were demanding to be treated as though their lives actually meant something and we just can't have that.
Starbucks' union drive comes amid much a broader national labor
movement spanning multiple industries across the country. Last month, in
a strike wave known as "Striketober," tens of thousands of workers at
companies like John Deere, Frito-Lay, Nabisco, Kellogg, and McDonald's
organized work stoppages over unethical working conditions and low pay.
According to Cornell's Labor Action Tracker, the share of workers on strike last month jumped
to 25,000 – a marked departure from the three months prior, which saw
an average of 10,000. Many experts and labor advocates told Salon that
strikes are being driven largely by a growing sense of dissatisfaction
amongst essential workers as the pandemic wanes.
Corrina A. Christensen, Director of Public Relations &
Communications of the BCTGM International Union, which represents
workers at Frito-Lay, Kellogg, and Nabisco, said that the strikes have
"everything to do with workers being fed up with employers bent on
disrespecting their work and demanding take-aways in wages, benefits,
forcing overtime…after they were upheld as 'essential.'"
That is the line the CDC is trying to hold. The bosses who have the ears of policymakers have succeeded in defining 5 days of additional sick leave as a "societal threat" so large that it actually outweighs the threat of pandemic COVID. The article quoted above is primarily about the organizing effort at Starbucks in Buffalo. In this article, the workers involved in that campaign refer to the "fear culture" brought to bear against them by management.
“Most of the workers I talk to
are almost immediately on board,” Murray says. He joined the organizing
effort two months ago, and has been talking to his coworkers ever since.
He says that not only do organizers have to educate everyone on what
a union is all about, they also face a latent level of fear among
employees that they could be targeted for retaliation, particularly now
that the union drive has gone public.
“[Coworkers] were saying, ‘I’m
scared, can Starbucks do something to us?’ That broke my heart, because
that fear culture has already been cultivated,” says Gianna Reeve,
a shift supervisor who has been helping with the organizing effort. “It really hurts. This is an opportunity that we can be stronger.”
Fear of retaliation is the greatest weapon the bosses have against workers. And it permeates the atmosphere of most service industry jobs like Starbucks where the boss can demand not only compliance in deed but also in attitude. Standards in service jobs are subjective. Workers can be made accountable not only for the amount of work they produce but for arbitrarily defined perceptions of that work. Here is what that looks like in practice.
Did you show up for that twelve hour shift on a holiday? Were you on your feet the whole time mixing hundreds of pumpkin spice lattes during the fall rush? Ahhh but see you weren't quite "WARM AND WELCOMING" enough as you went about that so we are going to have to punish you again.
Service industry bosses are absolute tyrants. Workers organizing against that kind of intense intimidation need all the help and encouragement they can get. Which is why having a strong labor influence in the halls of power is so important. When a government agency has a chance to step in and put its thumb on the scale, it can make a big difference. Joe Biden's CDC has chosen to intervene on behalf of the bosses. It even seems like they are rubbing it in the workers' faces by amplifying the bosses' intimidating rhetoric.
According to this CDC ad, workers have a clear choice. Their health or their job. If you are one of the good ones, the poster implies you will choose to work your shifts. If you are one of the good ones, in fact, you may not even "tolerate being at home." At least that's what CDC says.
“Our guidance was conservative before. It had said 10 days of
isolation,” Walensky told CNN. “But in the context of the fact that we
were going to have so many more cases — many of those would be
asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic — people would feel well enough to be
at work, they would not necessarily tolerate being home, and that they
may not comply with being home, this was the moment that we needed to
make that decision and those changes.”
Clearly these people care about your well being.